I won The Painter's Apprentice by Laura Morelli on Goodreads as a result of an error. The publisher accidentally offered too many copies for their print giveaway. So the author generously agreed to give away free digital copies via Book Funnel. That's the format in which I acquired my review copy, and this is my honest review.
Venice is a unique city that has an aura of magic. I enjoy visiting Venice through the pages of a book. Several years ago I reviewed a rather unusual mystery with a memorable perspective on 16th century Venice called The Aquatic Labyrinth by Alastair Fontana here. The last book I reviewed on this blog was the Laurie R. King mystery, Island of the Mad which brought me to Fascist Venice in the 1920's. You can find out more about King's novel here. Morelli's book took me to an earlier dark era in Venice's past when the city was afflicted by plague.
I primarily wanted to read this book because I have a special interest in woman protagonists who are artists. Since Laura Morelli is an art historian, I thought she would have insights to share about the world of artists in Renaissance Venice which would provide context for the story of her fictional protagonist, Maria Bartolini.
Maria played a role in the creation of works of art that I normally don't even think about. She was a gilder. Gilding is a decorative aspect of art. Frames were often gilded with gold leaf, but gold leaf was also added to portraits and other types of paintings to display the wealth of the subjects or a luxurious environment. There were also fancy gilded boxes that were made as gifts. Maria used molds to shape the gold in a variety of designs. It was unusual for a woman to become a gilder. Maria was trained by her father who was himself a gilder. Her father's reputation and Maria's skill gained her the respect of painters and wealthy clients.
Maria fell in love with Cristiano who is called a Moor. In practice, 16th century Venetians didn't really distinguish between Africans and Arabs. Both were subject to prejudice. See Laura Morelli's brief article on the subject here. Maria showed courage in standing by this relationship despite all obstacles. She also showed a great deal of fortitude in enduring losses due to the plague.
Another female character that I would have liked to know better was Cristiano's mother, Zenobia. Given my association of that name with the Syrian Warrior Queen, I wonder if she came from Syria where the name Zenobia was popular. One of Laura Morelli's questions for book clubs was which character's viewpoint I would choose for this novel other than Maria's. My choice is definitely Zenobia. I would like to find out more about her history and how she brought up her son to rise above Venetian prejudice.
The Painter's Apprentice contains a great deal of drama and tragedy, but it ends on a heartwarming note that leaves readers with a feeling of optimism for the future. Although I wondered if all of Maria's choices were wise, I ended up respecting Maria for her determination.
Showing posts with label Zenobia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Zenobia. Show all posts
Friday, July 13, 2018
Monday, December 14, 2015
Daughter of Sand and Stone by Libbie Hawker: Blog Tour and Review
Welcome to this stop on the TLC Book Tour for:
DAUGHTER OF SAND AND STONE by Libbie Hawker
Publication Date December 1, 2015.
Description from Amazon.com:
REVIEW
I've been looking forward to this book ever since I read that Libbie Hawker was writing it. This year I reviewed her Pocahontas novel on Book Babe here. I found it interesting and absorbing. Daughter of Sand and Stone is a book dealing with Queen Zenobia of Palmyra. She was a warrior queen and a rebel against the Romans like another favorite of mine, Queen Boudica of the Iceni. I lick my chops and salivate when I learn about historical fiction dealing with Zenobia. I received a copy from the publisher via Net Galley in return for this honest review.
The first time I read a Zenobia novel I was disappointed. It was The Rise of Zenobia by J. D. Smith. I reviewed Smith's version on Book Babe here. My biggest problem with it was that Zenobia wasn't the protagonist. It was her general, Zabdas. I felt distanced from Zenobia. In Daughter of Sand and Stone, Zabdas plays an important role, but the main perspective is very definitely Zenobia's.
I feel that it's also important to mention the recent destruction of Palmyra by ISIS in the context of any current review of a book about Zenobia. Here is an article about it from the U.K. Guardian. Zenobia loved her city and it means a great deal to modern day Syrians who are opposed to ISIS. Ancient Palmyra and Zenobia are essential parts of our world heritage, but they particularly belong to the history of Syria. It seems to me that anyone who participates in preserving the memory of ancient Palmyra and Zenobia is engaging in an act of defiance against those who seek to destroy them. That's what Daughter of Sand and Stone means to me. It's an act of defiance.
Like Libbie Hawker's Pocahontas, her Zenobia is ambitious. In the case of Pocahontas, it's definitely a flaw due to lack of maturity. She simply craves attention and her ambitions are comparatively small scale. On the other hand, Hawker's Zenobia wants an empire and to reign as Queen in Egypt like her maternal ancestor, Cleopatra. She is continually told by members of her family and later by a Roman Emperor that she is going beyond the bounds of women's sphere. I think this is a strength. We need women like Zenobia. She had courage, vision and intelligence. She deserved to succeed.
Hawker extrapolates from Roman primary sources for the ending of her novel. In Hawker's very detailed Author's Note she says that a number of writers on Zenobia don't believe the official Roman version and I confess that I don't either. Within the context of the book, it was anti-climactic. So in addition to my feelings that it was out of character and not a fit ending for Zenobia, it wasn't a good ending from a dramatic perspective.
Yet up until that ending, I was cheering on Zenobia and feeling so delighted that we got a modern novel about the Warrior Queen of Palmyra in which she lives and breathes. It may not be the ideal Zenobia novel, but it perpetuates her legacy at a time when I think it's particularly important to do so.
***************
Links for more information about Daughter of Sand and Stone
DAUGHTER OF SAND AND STONE by Libbie Hawker
Publication Date December 1, 2015.
Description from Amazon.com:
When Zenobia takes control of her own fate, will the gods punish her audacity?
Zenobia, the proud daughter of a Syrian sheikh, refuses to marry against her will. She won’t submit to a lifetime of subservience. When her father dies, she sets out on her own, pursuing the power she believes to be her birthright, dreaming of the Roman Empire’s downfall and her ascendance to the throne.
Defying her family, Zenobia arranges her own marriage to the most influential man in the city of Palmyra. But their union is anything but peaceful—his other wife begrudges the marriage and the birth of Zenobia’s son, and Zenobia finds herself ever more drawn to her guardsman, Zabdas. As war breaks out, she’s faced with terrible choices.
From the decadent halls of Rome to the golden sands of Egypt, Zenobia fights for power, for love, and for her son. But will her hubris draw the wrath of the gods? Will she learn a “woman’s place,” or can she finally stake her claim as Empress of the East?
Zenobia, the proud daughter of a Syrian sheikh, refuses to marry against her will. She won’t submit to a lifetime of subservience. When her father dies, she sets out on her own, pursuing the power she believes to be her birthright, dreaming of the Roman Empire’s downfall and her ascendance to the throne.
Defying her family, Zenobia arranges her own marriage to the most influential man in the city of Palmyra. But their union is anything but peaceful—his other wife begrudges the marriage and the birth of Zenobia’s son, and Zenobia finds herself ever more drawn to her guardsman, Zabdas. As war breaks out, she’s faced with terrible choices.
From the decadent halls of Rome to the golden sands of Egypt, Zenobia fights for power, for love, and for her son. But will her hubris draw the wrath of the gods? Will she learn a “woman’s place,” or can she finally stake her claim as Empress of the East?
REVIEW
I've been looking forward to this book ever since I read that Libbie Hawker was writing it. This year I reviewed her Pocahontas novel on Book Babe here. I found it interesting and absorbing. Daughter of Sand and Stone is a book dealing with Queen Zenobia of Palmyra. She was a warrior queen and a rebel against the Romans like another favorite of mine, Queen Boudica of the Iceni. I lick my chops and salivate when I learn about historical fiction dealing with Zenobia. I received a copy from the publisher via Net Galley in return for this honest review.
The first time I read a Zenobia novel I was disappointed. It was The Rise of Zenobia by J. D. Smith. I reviewed Smith's version on Book Babe here. My biggest problem with it was that Zenobia wasn't the protagonist. It was her general, Zabdas. I felt distanced from Zenobia. In Daughter of Sand and Stone, Zabdas plays an important role, but the main perspective is very definitely Zenobia's.
I feel that it's also important to mention the recent destruction of Palmyra by ISIS in the context of any current review of a book about Zenobia. Here is an article about it from the U.K. Guardian. Zenobia loved her city and it means a great deal to modern day Syrians who are opposed to ISIS. Ancient Palmyra and Zenobia are essential parts of our world heritage, but they particularly belong to the history of Syria. It seems to me that anyone who participates in preserving the memory of ancient Palmyra and Zenobia is engaging in an act of defiance against those who seek to destroy them. That's what Daughter of Sand and Stone means to me. It's an act of defiance.
Like Libbie Hawker's Pocahontas, her Zenobia is ambitious. In the case of Pocahontas, it's definitely a flaw due to lack of maturity. She simply craves attention and her ambitions are comparatively small scale. On the other hand, Hawker's Zenobia wants an empire and to reign as Queen in Egypt like her maternal ancestor, Cleopatra. She is continually told by members of her family and later by a Roman Emperor that she is going beyond the bounds of women's sphere. I think this is a strength. We need women like Zenobia. She had courage, vision and intelligence. She deserved to succeed.
Hawker extrapolates from Roman primary sources for the ending of her novel. In Hawker's very detailed Author's Note she says that a number of writers on Zenobia don't believe the official Roman version and I confess that I don't either. Within the context of the book, it was anti-climactic. So in addition to my feelings that it was out of character and not a fit ending for Zenobia, it wasn't a good ending from a dramatic perspective.
Yet up until that ending, I was cheering on Zenobia and feeling so delighted that we got a modern novel about the Warrior Queen of Palmyra in which she lives and breathes. It may not be the ideal Zenobia novel, but it perpetuates her legacy at a time when I think it's particularly important to do so.
***************
Links for more information about Daughter of Sand and Stone
Author's website: http://libbiehawker.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/libbie.hawker?fref=ts&ref=br_tf
Libbie Hawker’s TLC Book Tours TOUR
STOPS:
Monday, November 30th: Peeking Between the Pages
Tuesday, December 1st: Bibliotica
Tuesday, December 1st: Life is Story
Wednesday, December 2nd: Reading Reality
Thursday, December 3rd: A Chick Who Reads
Friday, December 4th: Thoughts from an Evil Overlord
Monday, December 7th: Luxury Reading
Tuesday, December 8th: Spiced Latte Reads
Wednesday, December 9th: Book Dilettante
Thursday, December 10th: Mom’s Small Victories
Friday, December 11th: Book Nerd
Monday, December 14th: 100 Pages a Day…Stephanie’s Book Reviews
Monday, December 14th: Book Babe
Tuesday, December 15th: A Bookish Affair
Wednesday, December 16th: The Reader’s Hollow
Thursday, December 17th: Books a la Mode – author guest post
Monday, December 21st: Raven Haired Girl
Tuesday, December 22nd: The Lit Bitch
Friday, December 25th: Patricia’s Wisdom
Tuesday, December 29th: I’m Shelfish
Tuesday, December 29th: Time 2 Read
Wednesday, December 30th: Broken Teepee
Labels:
Blog Tours,
Book Reviews,
Palmyra,
Roman Empire,
Warrior Queens,
Zenobia
Thursday, July 10, 2014
The Rise of Zenobia: Only The Beginning of a Spectacular Life Story
I have a strong interest in Zenobia, the ancient Warrior Queen of Palmyra, Syria. I'm not interested because she was a queen, and I don't care about her being a descendant of Cleopatra. My main interest is that Zenobia rebelled against the Roman Empire. That's why I entered a giveaway on the Historical Fictionistas group on Goodreads for The Rise of Zenobia by J.D. Smith.
I knew from the summary that the central character was not Zenobia. He was a male relative of hers named Zabdas. Zabdas was well portrayed, but the most dramatic event that had happened in his life occurred before the novel began. I also noticed that he's a go with the flow kind of guy who lets others make decisions for him. Maybe it's because he spent so many years as a slave. He may resent those decisions, but he doesn't resist them.
Zenobia refuses to just go along. When the Kingdom of Palmyra is in jeopardy from a massive invasion she does what she can to prevent it. The trouble is that she seems to get whatever she wants. I felt that this lessened the suspense to a very great degree.
The other problem is that this is book one, and it doesn't cover the aspect of Zenobia's life that really interests me. So I liked it, but my enthusiasm was limited. It seems likely that I will prefer the second book.
I knew from the summary that the central character was not Zenobia. He was a male relative of hers named Zabdas. Zabdas was well portrayed, but the most dramatic event that had happened in his life occurred before the novel began. I also noticed that he's a go with the flow kind of guy who lets others make decisions for him. Maybe it's because he spent so many years as a slave. He may resent those decisions, but he doesn't resist them.
Zenobia refuses to just go along. When the Kingdom of Palmyra is in jeopardy from a massive invasion she does what she can to prevent it. The trouble is that she seems to get whatever she wants. I felt that this lessened the suspense to a very great degree.
The other problem is that this is book one, and it doesn't cover the aspect of Zenobia's life that really interests me. So I liked it, but my enthusiasm was limited. It seems likely that I will prefer the second book.
Labels:
Ancient Times,
Book Reviews,
Historical Fiction,
Zenobia
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)